This week’s class was a continuation of the social self. Because I have recently re-injured my foot, I have decided to dedicate this post to a self-enhancement strategy that I have become found of because of such injuries.
According to Taylor
(1989), we have a fundamental desire to maintain a positive viewpoint about ourselves
and our circumstances, and in order to protect this positive viewpoint we use
self-enhancement strategies. The
strategy that I use most often consists of making a downward social comparison.
This type of comparison involves comparing yourself to others who are
worse off than you are. For example, if
people’s self-esteem is threatened, they are likely to compare themselves to
people who are less than they are
(e.g., less successful or less fortunate) as a way to protect their own
self-esteem (Hakmiller, 1966).
Furthermore, downward social comparisons allow people to maintain a
positive outlook on their life (Aspinwall & Taylor, 1993).
Downward social comparisons have noticeably become more
important in my life since my foot injury on July 4, 2008. On this day, I accidentally hit my foot on a
desk leg, and the desk leg slid between the last two toes on my left foot. Naturally, a week later I found out that I
had broken the bones in that area, but I was told that everything should heal
within 4-6 weeks. After the sixth week,
I still could not move any of my toes or my ankle, and the pain was spreading
up my leg. In February of 2009, I found
out that I had actually developed a nerve disease when I had initially hit my
foot and it was now spreading up my leg.
This nerve disease is called Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy (RSD) and is a
life-long condition, meaning there is no cure.
Because of RSD, I had lost 95% mobility from my ankle down, and it hurt
to do simple things such as walk, shower, and wear socks. Because I had limited mobility, I was also
forced to quit marching band (I had to be on the side lines) and to step down
as section leader for my last two years of high school. It is safe to say that I was not a happy
camper during this time.
Although I cried myself to sleep most of the time (because
of the pain and the frustration), I kept telling myself: “Things could be
worse.” In fact, I knew that things
could be worse because the doctor who helped me with my pain management told me
a story about a woman who got a paper cut on her thumb, developed RSD, and then
the RSD spread from one arm to the other arm before she was able to get any
type of treatment. So at this point although
I was in a lot of pain, I was thankful that we had identified the problem
before the RSD had spread to both legs.
In a similar vein, two years ago my mom was watching one of those
mystery medical shows (the ones where the person didn’t know what was wrong
with them, but by the end of the show we find out what was wrong with them). This particular episode was about a woman who
was on bed-rest for 14 years because she was in horrible pain. During this show, my mom was shocked to
realize that the woman’s symptoms matched my symptoms but to a greater
extent. At then end of the episode, my
mom’s suspicions were verified in that this woman did end up having RSD. After hearing about this episode from my mom,
this woman’s story became part of my downward social comparison because at
least I wasn’t force to stay in bed for 14 years because I was experiencing
unimaginable pain.
Since 2009, I have had various block injections in a main
nerve located on my back. These
injections paralyze the nerve to decrease
their sensitivity and firing. I also did
physical therapy as a way to get more mobility and strength in my foot. Right now, or at lest before my re-injury a
couple of weeks ago, the pain as become more manageable, showering doesn’t
hurt, and I can wear socks and shoes you can lace. But walking is still a day-to-day challenge,
my dancing is limited, and I do not think I will ever be able to run or jump
ever again because my foot does not do well with impact force. It is very frustrating not being able to do
things that I loved to do before my accident and not being able to do things
that I might not have liked but at least could still do if I wanted to or
needed to. In all, I have had to
drastically change certain areas of my life.
I also now have to be careful in general not to injury my foot because the
RSD will be triggered even more each time, which is unfortunate because for the
first time since 2008, I re-injured my foot and am now dealing with even more
RSD symptoms. Hopefully, the doctors and
specialists here in Georgetown
will be able to help me in the coming weeks. But hey, at least the nerve damage
hasn’t spread past my left leg or hasn’t caused me to be on bed-rest and miss
all my classes and flunk out of school, so I’m hopeful to an extent!
_________________________
Aspinwall, L. G. & Taylor, S. E. (1993). The effect of
social comparison direction, threat, and self-esteem on affect,
self-evaluation, and expected success. Journal
of Personality and Social Psychology. 64,
708-722.
Hakmiller, K. L. (1966). Threat as a determinant of downward
comparison. Journal of Experimental
Social Psychology (Suppl. 1), 32-39.
Taylor, S. E. (1989). Positive
illusion: Creative self-deceptions and the healthy mind. New York: Basic Books.
First of all, I truly sympathize with what you are going through. I know it is really hard, and I think that you do a wonderful job of being optimistic and positive about your situation. Many people in your condition would use it as an excuse as to why they can't do things (like being involved in a sorority or being a TA), but you don't handicap yourself just because you have this condition. I think it is very admirable and sets a good example to other students ;)
ReplyDeleteSecond, I can definitely relate to using downward social comparisons to make myself feel better about certain situations in my life. As you know, I had my first son when I was 17 years old. I have gone through a lot of hard times, obviously due to choices I made as a teenager, but I do not regret having my son at all. However, there have been many times when I have wished that things had been easier for me, or times when I wished I would have gotten to do all of the things that other teens and kids in their early twenties got to do. These days, whenever I reflect on my life and things I have gone through and overcome, it makes me feel good to realize that things really could have been worse. I know that statistically teen parents are less likely to graduate high school (which I did), less likely to go to college and graduate (I got this opportunity and graduate in May!), and are more likely to live in poverty (luckily, I have great parents that help me so this is not a problem for me). I also know that babies born to teenage moms often have birth defects or learning disabilities (thank God, my boys are both healthy and very smart!). Whenever I think about all of these things that could have gone the other way for me and my boys I realize that we are truly blessed. I can honestly say that I am happy with the way my life has turned out, and I pray for the others who are not as lucky as I am....because let's face it, not everyone is. So thank you, downward social comparisons, for helping me to realize that I have it pretty darn good :)
Thank you for your comment! I totally agree. Even right now as I am trying to deal with these new symptoms, I look back and see how RSD has made me a stronger person and more appreciative of the things I have been blessed with. It has also made me more sympathetic to others' plights and aware of potential 'invincible' conditions (such as nerve damage). As I have gotten older, I am also not so quick to judge others in certain situations. Again, thank you for commenting and for your support :)
Delete